11 September 2010

"Dropping the Mask" by Timothy J.A. O'Donnell

Imagine performing an abortion while you are pregnant. Imagine your baby kicking inside your womb as you dismember the child in your patient's womb. Unthinkable? Or is it courageous?

Read this New York Times article for the grisly and shocking reality of two young female doctors that perform abortion.

http://www.nytimes.com/2010/07/18/magazine/18abortion-t.html

In what follows, you will read my letter to the editor of the NYT to this article.

Dear Editor:

Thank you for dropping the mask.


The New Abortion Providers gives ample evidence of how journalistic standards have been compromised. It is hardly surprising to find a NYT article careening portside, but the shallowness of thought and lack of balance is stunning. Lifting Terry Randall, a known crackpot, as the Pro-life figurehead and juxtaposing him with Tiller (considered by many as a killer and extremist) polarizes rather than clarifies the issues. Moral equivalency is on display; the number of abortionists killed without any reference to the millions of dead children – victims of abortion and a false choice - , the mothers who have severe spiritual, mental, and physical problems from abortion, or the violence against Pro-life supporters is a vacuous and misleading caricature of the facts and the principles involved.

Abortion is a ghastly industry that harms women, steals fatherhood, and kills children. In a recent change in strategy, exemplified in this article, the fact that the abortion industry is increasingly more explicit and direct about the aim of abortion: the killing of the child. Biology, embryology, philosophy, and theology all present strong reasonable arguments and evidence against abortion because it is a grave injustice to the children killed.

Ask the tough questions: What is the unborn? Is the unborn a member of the human family?

"If the unborn are not human, no justification for elective abortion in necessary. But if the unborn are human, no justification for elective abortion is adequate." (Koukl, Precious Unborn Human Persons, p. 7)

Note too that there is zero reference to the baby having intrinsic value, special dignity, an unrepeatable gift, and made in the image and likeness of God.

Sadly, the article makes clear the gruesome reality of abortion as dismembering a little person alive and vulnerable in their mother’s womb, yet they are ok with that.

The mask if off.

18 October 2009

Debate between Prof George and Prof Kmiec on the Sanctity of Human Life

An exceellent debtae at Catholic University earlier in 2009 between two prominent Catholic professors Dr. Robert P. George of Princeton and Prof. Doug Kmiec. the topic is the sanctity of human life moderated by Prof. Mary Glendon. If you are interste...d in the central moral issue of our age - the sanctity of human life - or, if you are interested in the controversy over Notre Dame's choices of late, then this video is well worth the time. Both debators are Catholic, pro-life, lawyers, and professors but differ on the mens by which they promote pro-life policies affetcing life issues.

16 October 2009

Real Choice: fear of Trust?

The Bioethics Defense Fund (BDF) produced this beautiful video of one of the pivotal questions of our age: fear or Trust?

"BDF's powerful 2-minute YouTube video will inspire and uplift you! With moving simplicity, it sets forth the real choice: Fear or Trust.This video is part of the BDF BioDebate project. It's not a debate if only one side gets a hearing. The mainstream media promotes a culture of death, and BioDebate gives YOU the opportunity to use the power of video to promote a culture of life."

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=39dK237zac8&feature=player_profilepage

03 October 2009

Reflecting on praying before an abortion mill.

Outside of the abortion processing machine, in the cool wind and cloudy skies, witnesses gathered together for a common cause: relief to the scourge of abortion. It was spiritually jarring and emotionally disturbing to stand in close proximity to such a thoroughly malevolent asylum. Beginning with recitation of the Holy Rosary one nevertheless finds a way to accept the graces offered to enter into a deep meditation.

But then – mirabile dictu – through the hubbub of Georgetown Road, there was a tiny whisper of sanity: Nothing is more precious and sacred than the gift of human life. Emmanuel – God with us – is here.

Noted Pro-life apologist Stephanie Gray remarks “There is something very important and beautiful about the nature of women: that they are to be mothers (whether in spiritual or physical form). A pregnant woman becomes a tabernacle enveloping a person made in the image of the Divine”. The supreme exemplar of this insight is the Incarnation of Our Savior in the most blessed womb of Mary the Great Mother of God.

In its most profound reality, love is essentially a gift; love begins with the couple but does not end with them, because it makes them capable of the greatest possible gift, the gift by which they become cooperators with God for giving life to a new human person. Thus the couple, while giving themselves to one another, give not just themselves but also the reality of children, who are a living reflection of their love, a permanent sign of conjugal unity and a living and inseparable synthesis of their being a father and a mother (cf. Familiaris Consortio, 14).

Yet, contesting authentic giftedness stands the prevailing attitudes of the clique (this small, sectarian coterie of mainstream abortioneers). Abortion opposes love; the evil of abortion dissolves unity; the organized slaughter of innocents extends its weeping darkness to fill yet another vast cemetery.

Perceiving hidden and secret things before us in the depths of Planned Parenthood’s building, fortified and guarded with arms as it was, the realization that prayer alone has the power to break through the steel, brick, and security glass happens. Watching Dr. Havoc drive off in his glamorous sports car after his laborious day at the office emptying tummy bumps was chilling.

Pope Benedict XVI’s reflection reminds us all of the deepest meaning of authentic love.

“Love is Suffering”

We must think of love as suffering. Only if we are ready to endure it as suffering and thus ever again to accept each other and once again take the other to ourselves, only then can a lifelong relationship develop. If, on the contrary, we say when we get to the critical point, I want to avoid that, and we separate, then what we are really renouncing is the true opportunity that is to be found in man and woman being turned toward each other and in the reality of love (Pope Benedict, God and the Word).


Ad Jesum per Mariam,
Timothy J.A. O’Donnell

09 September 2009

"Killing Girls is Bad, Killing Boys is OK" by Doug Bandow

In this article from American Spectator, the incoherency of the pro-abortion position is on display.
http://spectator.org/archives/2009/09/04/killing-girls-is-bad-killing-b
Shining a bright light on yet another contradiction to be found in the abortioneer's position is indeed helpful. No other action destroys more human lives than abortion. We ought not be surprised when certain nefarious characters bend abortion to further evil ends. Once society accepts say slavery as an institution, it is not long before additional evils develop within the structure of the moral evil: cruelty, rape, deprivation.
The human person is created Imagio Dei - directly and inetionally - and every human person desrves to have their fundamental right to life preserved and protected from being unjustly taken.

05 July 2009

What's in a Name?

What’s in a name?
The twaddle over Dr. Tiller’s nickname Tiller the Baby Killer has fermented into a brackish attack on conservatives who report in glaring detail on the issue of abortion. To be sure, Dr. Tiller’s curricular vitae, his alleged crimes and recent murder, have incited liberals to cry hate crime and domestic terrorism from their cul-de-sac. But was the moniker Tiller the Baby Killer in fact truthful?
Every time abortioneers (i.e. abortion advocates) are confronted with the gruesome reality of abortion, its intrinsic evil, the irrefutable biological evidence that these are children – whole, distinct, living human beings – abortioneers dipsy doodle to avoid the gathered facts, softly whimpering nolo contendere.
Scampering away from the ugliness of an actual abortion, the NARAL crowd now boasts of a website to enshrine Dr. Tiller’s memory as the great champion of so-called reproductive rights. The president of NARAL Pro-Choice America Nancy Keenan issued a statement in reaction to Dr. Tiller’s murder:

What happened to Dr. Tiller is part of an ongoing pattern of extreme anti-choice violence and intimidation that seeks, by any means necessary, to deny women access to the safe, legal abortion care they need. This use of inflammatory rhetoric and acts of violence must stop.

Since when has defending life by way of philosophical arguments, massive scientific data, and (dare I say) Christian theological principles for affirming the sanctity of human life, its intrinsic worth and dignity, constitute inflammatory rhetoric? It doesn’t. Nonetheless, abortioneers will not answer the fundamental question: What are the unborn? For Scott Klusendorf president of Life Training Institute, in his new book The Case for Life: Equipping Christians to Engage the Culture, it is the one question that trumps all others. That is the crux of the debate. When President Obama was asked when life begins during the primary, he gave his infamous manqué: “answering that question with specificity is above my pay grade.” Orders from Planned Parenthood headquarters have insisted toe the line.

By design, the revelries of liberalism croon the primacy of women’s reproductive healthcare and reproductive rights, yet elective abortion has absolutely nothing in common with healthcare or human rights. Abortion stands for, if words are to signify real concepts or anything at all, damaging mothers both physically and emotionally, forever traumatizing our teens, and abortion is always an act of brutal violence that destroys innocent human persons.
True to form, abortioneers spurt that it’s the name-calling that is the problem, not the millions of dead children or wounded lives damaged by the abortion aftermath. What is consequential is the Big Hate , writes Paul Krugman. In his briny opinion, the real danger is not institutionalized abortion en masse, but rather the “Politicians and media organizations wind up such people at their, and our, peril.” A concierge for leftist dogma, Krugman smears drek on an assembly of conservatives including Bill O’Reilly, Rush Limbaugh, and Jon Voight for their downright meanness. It’s positively gauche to speak about the particulars of such a thing.

To be sure, liberals customarily wag their fingers at those conservative scoundrels who have the impudence to tell it like it is. Ann Coulter sets the record straight – 49 million to five - over the past 36 years since Roe v. Wade. Speaking tongue-in-cheek, Coulter offers her version of lex taliones:

I wouldn't kill an abortionist myself, but I wouldn't want to impose my moral values on others. No one is for shooting abortionists. But how will criminalizing men making difficult, often tragic, decisions be an effective means of achieving the goal of reducing the shootings of abortionists?

What is made plain is the moral baby-talk of abortioneers.
Going further, was Dr. George Tiller a killer of babies? Did he have blood on his hands?
Let us establish the truth or falsity of two claims: first, abortion kills the child in the womb ipso facto or the procedure would not be an abortion. It is the only so-called medical procedure in which a living baby means the procedure was botched. I wonder if Dr. Tiller had a refund policy? Dead baby in a toilet, pay five grand; your child lives, you keep your money.
Under Obamacare, this place of darkness, anguish, and death will only extend itself into yet another vast cemetery in disturbing tribute to humanity’s cruelty to the most vulnerable.
Second, it is no stretch at all, when one considers the scientific evidence, that human life is intrinsically valuable, a gift to be welcomed and loved. From a logically coherent argument, Professor Patrick Lee, McAleer Professor of Bioethics, Director of the Institute of Bioethics, Franciscan University of Steubenville sums up in his work Pro Life Arguments from Substantial Identity:
What is intrinsically valuable is what we are.
1. You and I are intrinsically valuable.
2. You and I are intrinsically valuable (in the sense of being subjects of rights) in virtue of what we are.
3. What we are are human physical organisms. (That is: you and I are essentially human physical organisms.)
4. But human physical organisms come to be at conception.
5. So, what we are comes to be at conception. (from 3 and 4) (You and I came to be at conception.
6. So, what is intrinsically valuable (as a subject of rights) comes to be at conception. (from 2 and 5)

Summa contra Tiller: he killed 60,000 human beings in their earliest stages of development, i.e. babies.
But did he have blood on his hands? Keeping in mind that Dr. Tiller the Child Killer specialite de la maison were late-term abortions, Congressman Henry Hyde (D-IL) captured the heart of the discussion when pleading with Congress in 1996 to overturn Clinton’s veto. He exhorted:

That we are even debating this issue, that we have to argue about the legality of an abortionist plunging a pair of scissors into the back of the tiny neck of a little child whose trunk, arms and legs have already been delivered, and then suctioning out his brains only confirms Dostoyevsky's harsh truth (Man can get used to anything the beast).

Congresses’ response was less than enthusiastic. It would be seven more years before a ban on partial-birth abortion became law under President Bush.
In his dissent written for the Stenberg v. Carhart dealing with partial-birth abortions illegal without providing exceptions to the mother, Justice Kennedy describes with vivid clarity the gruesome late abortion procedures:

The fetus, in many cases, dies just as a human adult or child would: It bleeds to death as it is torn from limb from limb (reproductive healthcare). ... The fetus can be alive at the beginning of the dismemberment process and can survive for a time while its limbs are being torn off (reproductive rights). Dr. Carhart agreed that “[w]hen you pull out a piece of the fetus, let’s say, an arm or a leg and remove that, at the time just prior to removal of the portion of the fetus, … the fetus [is] alive.” …. Dr. Carhart has observed fetal heartbeat via ultrasound with “extensive parts of the fetus removed,” id., at 64, and testified that mere dismemberment of a limb does not always cause death because he knows of a physician who removed the arm of a fetus only to have the fetus go on to be born “as a living child with one arm.” …. At the conclusion of a D&E abortion no intact fetus remains (reproductive choice). In Dr. Carhart’s words, the abortionist is left with “a tray full of pieces.”

Where is the left’s gibberish about hate speech? Where are the accusations that Justice Kennedy is whipping up violence for abortionists? There aren’t any because it’s an illogical and unjust connection to make; description is not by necessity prescriptive.

Picture introducing forceps to grab the extremities of each child - hands and arms, feet and legs, upper body and backbone, skull and face – that is, being torn limb from limb (Dilation and Evacuation Procedure) and filling tray after tray, year after year with pieces from his fresh kills.

Short of a Zen-like satori perhaps nothing will awaken abortioneers to the merciless, inhumane destruction of innocent children. In the end, Dr. Tiller was a paid thug with blood on his hands; he spilled gallons of it.